Net Exchange Response
Title: Why the disconnect between special education
labels and DSM diagnoses?
Date Posted: 7/6/2015
Question: Why is there such a disconnection between IDEA
classifications in schools and the DSM diagnoses given to children? Also, what impact has
this in implementing appropriate mental health services in schools?
Response: This question arises frequently because the matter confounds
parents, providers, and sometimes school staff and administrators. The following from the
Children's Hospital of Philadelphia may help in understanding the matter:
Medical Diagnosis Vs. Educational Eligibility for
Special Services: Important Distinctions...
"Parents are often surprised to learn that a medical diagnosis... does not automatically
entitle a student to special education services under the Individuals with Disabilities
Education Act (IDEA). Eligibility for special education services is based, rather, on an
educational determination of a disability, which includes meeting not just the criteria for
a specific disability ..., but also finding that a student is in need of special services.
Understanding the differences between a medical diagnosis and an educational
determination of eligibility for special education services can help parents become better
advocates for their children. A medical diagnosis... is made by a doctor or other specially
trained clinician by using symptom criteria set in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders (DSM), a book published by the American Psychological Association
(APA)....The DSM requires that symptoms limit and impair everyday functioning, but
this is to be interpreted broadly. By contrast, educational eligibility is decided by a team
comprised of various school professionals and a student’s parents. The team must find
that the student qualifies for services under IDEA. To be eligible, IDEA requires that a
student have at least one of 14 specified disabilities and be in need of special services.
... The primary difference between a medical diagnosis and an educational eligibility
determination is the impact the condition has on student learning. The educational team
(along with the parents) must conclude that autism interferes with learning and that the
student needs special services in order to make academic progress. Because of this
additional requirement, it is possible (and not infrequent) that a student has a medical
diagnosis ... but is ineligible for special education. (Students who are found ineligible for
special education may qualify for other services, such as accommodations, under the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973.)
Impact on Services
Parents need to understand how each service system –– medical and educational –– will
address treatment of their child .... The services and treatment options within each system
are varied and target different skills. For example, the education system focuses on
academic and functional skills, while it can be argued that the medical system attempts to
address problems from a more global perspective. Treatment within the medical system
usually consists of therapeutic interventions, such as behavior therapy, speech therapy,
occupational therapy, individual counseling, or medication intervention to treat
symptoms.... In the medical model, a diagnosis alone is usually sufficient to warrant
treatment.... As discussed above, educational services, by contrast, require more than just
a diagnosis; they require a finding that a student is in need of special services. Once it is
determined that services are needed, the particular services received will be determined
by an Individualized Education Program (IEP) team. Services may include some of the
same interventions as used in the medical system (for example behavior or speech
therapy), as well as other supports and specialized educational placements as determined
by the IEP team.
In summary, parents have a variety of options regarding treatment and have to decide
whether to pursue treatment through the medical system, the education system, or both. If
your concerns about your child are mostly behavioral and are mainly occurring in the
home, then you might want to pursue psychological treatment first. If your child is
having academic or behavioral difficulties at school, then you should pursue an
evaluation through the school district to see what resources are available to your child.
However, educational and medical services can be pursued simultaneously, which is
often the best strategy for children...."
Submit a request or comment now.
UCLA Center for Mental Health in Schools
Dept. of Psychology, P.O.Box 951563, Los Angeles, CA 90095.
email: Linda Taylor ~ web: http://smhp.psych.ucla.edu